Starkeyism

Home / The English constitution / The Human Rights Act

Key law

The Human Rights Act 1998

The law that brought the European Convention on Human Rights into British courts, and the one at the centre of the repeal debate.

What the Human Rights Act does

The Human Rights Act 1998 brought the rights in the European Convention on Human Rights into domestic law. Before it, a person had to take a case all the way to Strasbourg. Since it came into force in 2000, they can rely on those rights in a British court, and public authorities must act compatibly with them. The debate over the treaty behind it is on should the UK leave the ECHR.

How it works, section by section

The design matters. Section 2 tells courts to take account of Strasbourg rulings. Section 3 tells them to read all legislation, as far as possible, compatibly with the Convention. Section 4 lets senior courts issue a declaration of incompatibility when they cannot. Section 6 makes it unlawful for a public authority to breach Convention rights. One thing it does not do is let courts strike down an Act of Parliament, which is what keeps it, in theory, inside parliamentary sovereignty.

Why it is controversial

Critics argue that section 3 lets judges rewrite the meaning of statutes, and that section 2 tied British courts too tightly to Strasbourg. Supporters argue it simply lets ordinary people enforce basic rights at home, cheaply and quickly. On the Starkey account the Act is the hinge of the legal constitution, the single change that did most to move power to the courts.

The repeal debate

Repealing the Act, and replacing it with a British Bill of Rights, has moved from the fringe to Conservative and Reform policy, bound up with the question of leaving the ECHR. The Labour government wants to keep the Act and change how it is used. What a government could actually do is set out on the plan.

What is the Human Rights Act 1998?

It is a UK law that brings the European Convention on Human Rights into domestic law, so people can rely on those rights in British courts and public bodies must respect them.

Does the Human Rights Act let courts overrule Parliament?

No. Courts cannot strike down an Act of Parliament. They can issue a declaration of incompatibility under section 4, but the final decision stays with Parliament.

Is the Human Rights Act the same as the ECHR?

No. The ECHR is an international treaty. The Human Rights Act is the UK law that brings that treaty into domestic courts.